Aftermarket warranties, often referred to as extended warranties or vehicle service contracts, can sound like a great deal. Who wouldn’t want added protection against unexpected repair costs? The idea of having peace of mind when something goes wrong is appealing, but the reality is not all warranties are created equal.
At Harrell & Beverly Transmissions & Auto Repair, we’ve worked with hundreds of customers with aftermarket warranties, and we’ve seen the good, the bad, and the frustrating. While some policies provide real value, many come with fine print, exclusions, and red tape that leave customers paying out-of-pocket for repairs they thought were covered.
If you're considering purchasing an aftermarket warranty, or if you already have one, here’s what you need to know to avoid surprises.
What Is an Aftermarket Warranty?
An aftermarket warranty is a service contract that you purchase from a third-party provider (not the vehicle’s manufacturer). These warranties are different from the factory warranties that come with new vehicles.
They are often sold by:
✔️ Car dealerships (as part of a used car sale)
✔️ Independent warranty companies (offered online or through direct mail)
✔️ Banks or lenders (as an add-on to an auto loan)
The appeal is simple: for a set monthly or upfront fee, the warranty promises to cover certain repair costs, but that’s where things get tricky.
What Aftermarket Warranties DO Cover (When They Work Well)
When an aftermarket warranty is well-structured, it can provide genuine financial protection.
Good warranties typically cover:
✔️ Major Powertrain Components – Engine, transmission, and drivetrain failures
✔️ Some Electrical & AC Components – Sensors, switches, and compressors (varies by policy)
✔️ Certain High-Cost Repairs – Like timing chains, head gaskets, and fuel system failures
The best policies:
✅ Are backed by reputable companies with good reviews
✅ Clearly define covered components
✅ Have straightforward claims processes
We’ve seen customers get real value from their aftermarket warranties, when they fully understand what’s covered and work with a shop (like ours!) that knows how to navigate the claims process.
The Fine Print: What Aftermarket Warranties DON’T Cover
Here’s where many customers get caught off guard: most aftermarket warranties come with a long list of exclusions.
🚨 Common Limitations & Exclusions
Pre-Existing Conditions – If the issue existed before you purchased the warranty, it’s not covered.
Wear-and-Tear Parts – Brake pads, rotors, spark plugs, belts, hoses, and tires are usually NOT included.
Diagnostics & Testing Fees – Some warranties cover the repair, but not the cost to figure out what’s wrong.
Fluids, Filters & Seals – If your repair requires fresh coolant, oil, or transmission fluid, you may have to cover that cost.
Labor Rate Caps – If your warranty only pays up to a certain labor rate per hour and your shop’s rate is higher, you’ll owe the difference.
Required Pre-Approvals – Some companies require authorization before any repairs begin, which can slow down the process and result in denied claims if not followed correctly.
Many customers assume that "bumper-to-bumper" means everything is covered, but that’s rarely the case.
How to Avoid Warranty Frustration: Tips from Harrell & Beverly
We work with warranty companies every day, and we know how to get the best results for our customers. Here are some expert tips:
✅ Read the Contract Before You Buy – Know exactly what’s covered, what’s excluded, and any claim requirements.
✅ Ask About Labor Rate & Diagnostic Coverage – Some warranties don’t fully cover shop labor rates or testing fees.
✅ Understand the Claim Process – Some policies require pre-authorization, while others may reimburse you after you pay for the repair.
✅ Choose a Shop That Can Work with Warranties – Not all repair shops accept aftermarket warranties. At Harrell & Beverly, we can handle the claims process for you!
✅ Keep Up with Maintenance – Many warranty companies require proof that you’ve followed all factory-recommended services or they may deny coverage.
How We Handle Aftermarket Warranties at Harrell & Beverly
If you bring your vehicle to us with an aftermarket warranty, here’s what you can expect:
🔍 Thorough Testing & Evaluation – We diagnose the problem and provide a report to the warranty company.
📞 Claims Assistance – We communicate with the provider to verify coverage and ensure the best possible outcome.
💰 Upfront Transparency – If any costs aren’t covered, we’ll let you know before the work begins.
🔧 Quality Repairs, Guaranteed – Regardless of warranty coverage, we stand by our work and ensure you receive the best possible service.
Final Thoughts: Are Aftermarket Warranties Worth It?
Aftermarket warranties can be beneficial, but only if you understand the terms and choose a reputable provider. Many policies leave customers paying for repairs they thought were covered, which is why reading the fine print is crucial.
At Harrell & Beverly Transmissions & Auto Repair in Sanford, we believe in honesty, transparency, and doing what’s right for our customers. Whether you have an aftermarket warranty or not, we’re here to provide expert advice, quality service, and peace of mind when it comes to your vehicle repairs.
🚗 Have an aftermarket warranty and need a repair? Give us a call at 407-322-8415 and we’ll help you navigate the process and get the most from your coverage.
Comments